Lucifer's Cafe Menu
Lucifer's Cafe Menu
All sandwiches are served with either regular or our house-made spicy mayo, Dijon mustard, and a sprinkle of salt and pepper. Choose from a brioche bun, cheese bun, sourdough bread, whole wheat bread, or gluten-free bread. Prefer a milder option? Request it non-spicy!
Slices of roast beef piled with shredded lettuce, green pep- per, cucumber, tomato and red onion, topped off with a slice of cheddar cheese and drizzled with mustard, mayo and hot sauce.
Price: $8
Slices of ham stacked with shredded lettuce, pineapple chunks, green pepper and red onion, topped off with a slice of mozza- rella cheese and drizzled with mayo and hot sauce.
Price: $8
Slices of roast chicken piled with shredded lettuce, cucumber, green pepper, tomato, red onion and banana peppers, topped off with a slice of mozzarella cheese and drizzled with mustard, mayo and hot sauce.
Price: $8
Slices of capicola, bologna and salami stacked with shredded lettuce, green pepper, cucumber, tomato, red onion and banana pepper, topped off with a slice of mozarella cheese and driz- zled with mustard, mayo and hot sauce.
Price: $8
Tuna salad made with our house spicy mayo, topped with sprouts, pickles, cucumber and red onion.
Price: $8
Egg salad topped with sprouts, cucumber, green pepper, red onion and pickles, finished off with drizzles of mustard, mayo and hot sauce.
Price: $8
Smashed chickpeas topped with smashed avocado, sprouts, red onion and banana peppers, finished off with drizzles of our house spicy mayo and hot sauce.
Price: $8
A stack of shredded lettuce, sprouts, cucumber, green pepper, tomato, red onion, banana peppers and pickles topped off with a slice of cheddar and drizzled with mustard, mayo and hot sauce.
Price: $8
A soup and sandwich combination of your choice.
Price: $13
A heaping helping of marinated cold shrimp in our house chipotle sauce, comprised of 3 sauces we sell in-store, served on a bread of your choice, on a bed of shredded lettuce and shaved fennel, dusted with cocoa powder, topped with cucumber, red onion slices, finished with a bit of salt, pepper and a drizzle of our house spicy mayo.
Price: $10
Juicy slices of steak, tossed with caramelized red onions, green onions, melted provolone cheese, au jus, served on a toasted ciabatta bun with melted garlic butter.
Price: $12
Delicious smoked brisket meat, tossed with caramelized red onion, melted provolone cheese, drizzled in Sebastian’s bbq sauce, topped with sauerkraut, served on a toasted ciabatta bun with melted garlic butter and dijon mustard.
Price: $12
5 juicy meatballs, marinated in our house tomato pizza sauce, served with melted provolone cheese on a toasted ciabatta bun with garlic butter.
Price: $12
Six mouth-watering slices of bacon, served with fresh shredded lettuce, slices of tomato, drizzled with our house spicy mayo, stacked with three slices of toasted bread (your choice of either sourdough or whole wheat bread), with garlic butter.
Price: $10
Tender oven-roasted chicken breast, three slices of bacon, fresh shredded lettuce, slices of tomato and drizzled with our house spicy mayo, served on a toasted ciabatta bun with melted garlic.
Price: $12
A twist on the classic grilled cheese sandwich with three melted cheeses (provolone, mozzarella and cheddar cheese), on a stack of three slices of toasted bread (your choice of either sourdough or whole wheat bread), with garlic butter.
Price: $10
A classic and comforting sandwich of melted cheddar cheese, on toasted slices of garlic buttered bread (your choice of either sourdough or whole wheat bread). Choose your small soup (we always have our roasted garlic tomato soup on as a staple).
Price: $8
Juicy slices of steak, tossed with Sauce Club’s White Tiger Bulgogi Sauce, with caramelized red onions and green peppers, served on a bed of white basmati rice, drizzled with Kewpie Mayo, topped with fresh sliced green onions and sesame seeds.
Price: $12
A 12oz bowl from a rotating selection of meatless varieties. Ask your server.
Price: $6
A 12oz bowl from a rotating selection of meat varieties. Ask your server.
Price: $6
An eight ounce bowl of your choice of our two daily locally-made soups, with the roasted garlic tomato served daily and then one rotating either meat-based or vegetarian soup.
Price: $3.50
Fresh chopped romaine lettuce, alfalfa sprouts, diced tomatoes, diced cucumbers, diced green peppers, finely chopped red onions, slices of pickles, banana peppers, cubed mozzarella cheese, salt, pepper, and finished with a generous drizzle of your choice of three salad dressings.
1. Melinda's Hot Habanero Mustard (dressing is pre-mixed with extra virgin olive oil)
2. Queen Majesty Jalapeno, Tequila & Lime (dressing is pre-mixed with extra virgin olive oil)
3. Olive Oil & Balsamic Vinegar (no spice)
Price: $10
Tender pieces of chicken breast tossed with freshly chopped romaine lettuce, our house caesar salad dressing, crunchy croutons, shredded parmesan cheese, black pepper and topped with bacon bits.
Price: $12
An eight ounce bowl of a green salad, consisting of freshly shredded romaine lettuce, diced tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers and red onions with your choice of our three house salad dressings.
1. Melinda's Hot Habanero Mustard (dressing is pre-mixed with extra virgin olive oil)
2. Queen Majesty Jalapeno, Tequila & Lime (dressing is pre-mixed with extra virgin olive oil)
3. Olive Oil & Balsamic Vinegar (no spice)
Price: $3.50
12 chicken wings tossed in your choice of sauce. Choose from mild, medium, hot or super hot!
12 chicken wings tossed in your choice of mild sauce.
Price: $19.99
12 chicken wings tossed in your choice of medium sauce.
Price: $19.99
12 chicken wings tossed in your choice of hot sauce.
Price: $23.99
12 cauliflower wings tossed in your choice of sauce. Choose from mild, medium, hot or super hot!
12 cauliflower wings tossed in your choice of mild sauce.
Price: $15
12 cauliflower wings tossed in your choice of medium sauce.
Price: $15
12 cauliflower wings tossed in your choice of hot sauce.
Price: $18
Ten inch pizza shell, covered in our house pizza sauce and mozzarella and baked in our oven.
Price: $10
Ten inch pizza shell, covered in our house pizza sauce mozzarella, with a medley of Italian meats, red onions, green peppers and banana peppers.
Price: $13
Ten inch pizza shell, covered in our house pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese, with delicious ham and juicy pieces of pineapple.
Price: $13
8 ounces of locally sourced vanilla and/or chocolate ice cream with your choice of hot sauce topping.
8 ounces of locally-sourced vanilla and/or chocolate ice cream with Heartbeat’s Blueberry Habanero Hot Sauce on top.
Price: $3.50
8 ounces of locally-sourced vanilla and/or chocolate ice cream with Queen Majesty's Cocoa Ghost Hot Sauce on top.
Price: $3.50
8 ounces of locally-sourced vanilla and/or chocolate ice cream with Smokin' Dragon's Smoked Habanero & Peach Hot Sauce on top.
Price: $3.50
8 ounces of locally-sourced vanilla and/or chocolate ice cream with Heartbeat's Poirier's Louisiana Creole Maple Hot Sauce on top.
Price: $3.50
8 ounces of locally-sourced vanilla and/or chocolate ice cream with Heartbeat's Pineapple Habanero Hot Sauce on top.
Price: $3.50
8 ounces of locally-sourced vanilla and/or chocolate ice cream with Dawson's Sweet Pear Chili Hot Sauce on top.
Price: $3.50
All hot drinks come in a 12oz cup. Check our fridge for a rotating assortment of cold drinks as well!
Drip coffee from Muskoka Roastery Coffee Co.
Price: $3
Herbal or caffeinated tea. Just ask your server.
Price: $3
Something to warm you up, not that you'll need it!
Price: $3
Warm and cozy.
Price: $3